27th January 2002, 10:37 PM
Aadaab neerja ji.....
aapke kalaam ko dekh kar yuuN lagaa jaise aap isse likhte waqt "jagjit singh" ki ye ghazal sun rahii thiiN
apnii marzi se kahaan apne safar ke hum haiN
rukh hawaaoN ka jidhar ka hai udhar ke hum haiN
it looked like an exact copy of jagjit singh's ghazal ....just some words are changed which obviously didn't make any impression
kuch behtar likhne ki koshiish kareN.......
there's nothing wrong in being inspired by a ghazal and using the same qafiya and radeef in same meter BUT khayaal aapke apne hone chahiye......thats the most importnat thing...otherwise it's a copy ....like in this case
aapke kalaam meN "qafiya" missing hai...all the sher's are totally out of meter.....kisi bhi sher ke mafhuum saaf nahiiN hai....koshiish kariye ke aap apne khayaaloN ko madd'dey nazar rakh ke kuch likheN
this is my view about ur poem as u asked........please don't mind
maikasH
.........................................
is tarhe teri yaad meiN har shaam dhaley hai
goyaa koyi nagin si kalejey pe chaley hai
maikash
...............................
Last edited by maikasH; 27th January 2002 at 10:57 PM..
|